The missed opportunities of New Labour are heart-rending—not least when it comes to Europeby Andrew Adonis / December 11, 2017 / Leave a comment
A common problem in marriages is toxic co-dependency, and the tragedy of the political marriage of Gordon Brown and Tony Blair was precisely this condition.
Gordon would neither work closely with Tony nor challenge him. Had they worked closely and collaboratively, the Blair government might have been a worthy rival to the Attlee government which Gordon so admires for its transformational impact on social justice.
Maybe the reason this never happened is because Gordon never challenged Tony for the leadership. If he had stood in 1994, he would have got a true valuation of his modest support in the Parliamentary Labour Party, the unions and the wider membership, and would have had to come to terms with Tony as senior partner or find another job.
Equally, Tony should have broken with Gordon once their relationship became dysfunctional. I can’t fully explain why he did not do so after the 2001 election, when Tony won his second landslide and wanted to move on joining the Euro. Gordon and Ed Balls had already made clear that they would fight Euro membership, as part of a wider strategy of selectively opposing things dear to Tony in order to weaken and undermine him. But although he considered a ‘take it or leave it’ offer of the Foreign Office in 2001, Tony shrank back from wielding the knife.
Partly, I think, this was from lack of self-confidence (Peter Mandelson said he couldn’t imagine the meeting where Tony sacked Gordon), but partly also because Tony didn’t rate anyone else highly enough to believe that they could command the political middle ground as Chancellor. The great irony is that, had Gordon gone to the Foreign Office in 2001, he might just have stopped Iraq, Tony’s most ill-fated venture.