The Arab Spring may turn out better than you expectby Adel Dajani / November 23, 2011 / Leave a comment
Libyan women celebrate Gaddafi’s overthrow. They will not give up freedom easily
The armchair experts on Arab affairs are at it again. Still smarting from not predicting the Arab Spring and in hyping the case for the so-called Islamists who had nothing to do with the recent uprisings, many are now pontificating on what is happening—or going to happen—in Tunisia, Libya and Egypt. “The Arab Spring is becoming an Islamist takeover,” was the pronouncement of Con Coughlin in the Telegraph on 25th October.
Before the election results emerged in Tunisia, we were regaled by reports about widespread voter pessimism, low turnouts, rigged results and conflicts. Instead, we had a record turnout of over 90 per cent and a joyous response from people who had voted, for the first time in their lives, in a free and democratic election. Tunisians, unsurprisingly, have the same concerns as their European counterparts across the Mediterranean: the economy, unemployment and education. Why shouldn’t they?
Undeterred, many of these doom-mongers are now peddling the Islamists-under-the-bed scenario for post-election Tunisia. As an investor in the country, I think that a Nahda-led coalition could provide a strong framework for economic management, and for providing comfort levels for foreign investors. Such was the case for the ruling “Islamic” Justice and Development Party (AKP) in Turkey, which made the economy its priority, and has attracted record foreign investment. And if the Nahda coalition can’t manage the Tunisian economy, it will be the Tunisian electorate that decides whether to keep them in power—on the basis of their track record as managers, not their Islamic piety.
Another mantra of the doubters is the coming erosion of personal freedoms. I, for one, don’t think Tunisian women will accept any party that dramatically curtails their personal freedoms after half a century of rights comparable to their European counterparts. Why should Tunisian women react any differently to Europeans if they felt threatened? And do we really think that Arab electorates everywhere, having fought so hard for their freedom, will accept dictatorship from anyone else?
While the situation is more complicated in Egypt, the same line of argument on the economy will no doubt resonate with the Justice and Freedom party (linked to the Muslim Brotherhood) which faces voters from late November. Egyptians, just like everyone else, will be looking to the politicians they chose for economic solutions—to put money in their pockets—rather than empty rhetoric.