• Home
  • About us
  • Contact Us
  • Date/Time
  • Login
  • Subscribe

logo

  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economics & Finance
  • World
  • Arts & Books
  • Life
  • Science
  • Philosophy
  • Subscribe
  • Events
Home
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • Politics
  • Economics & Finance
  • World
  • Arts & Books
  • Life
  • Science
  • Philosophy
  • Subscribe
  • Events
  • Home
  • Magazine

Richard Wagner and the Valhalla state of mind

Richard Wagner's monumental Ring Cycle dramatises the eternal conflict between political power and human love

by Roger Scruton / June 16, 2016 / Leave a comment
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Email

Published in July 2016 issue of Prospect Magazine
World without end: a production of Richard Wagner's Götterdämmerung, the last opera in the Ring Cycle, at the China National Opera House in Beijing in 2015 ©Jin Liangkuai/Xinhua/Alamy Live News

World without end: a production of Richard Wagner’s Götterdämmerung, the last opera in the Ring Cycle, at the China National Opera House in Beijing in 2015 ©Jin Liangkuai/Xinhua/Alamy Live News

Richard Wagner’s four-opera cycle, Der Ring des Nibelungen, which he began in 1848 and on which he worked over the next two decades, is a comprehensive re-working of Old Norse myths, as recounted in the Icelandic Eddas. In Wagner’s story, the Viking gods are situated in a German landscape, along with Siegfried, hero of the German medieval epic Nibelungenlied. The Ring Cycle is about the gods, but the gods as conceived by a modern artist, whose concern is to create a myth that will comprehend all the principles—moral, political and spiritual—by which the modern world is governed. It is a story of the gods for people who have no gods to believe in.

That is why the Ring Cycle is of ever-increasing importance to music-lovers in our times. Its theme is the death of the gods, and what the gods have bequeathed to us, namely, the knowledge of, and longing for, the sacred. Until we recognise sacred moments, Wagner implies in this monumental work, we cannot live fully as free beings. These moments are the foundation of all our attempts to endow human life with significance. Despite the controversies that have surrounded this great work—its vast length, its dubious later associations with Nazi thought—it constantly grows on the collective imagination. It is not the answer to life in a post-religious world, but it asks the real questions, and shows us one fruitful way of confronting them. We should not be surprised that the forthcoming Opera North production at the Southbank in London was sold out within the space of a day.

When Wagner began work on the cycle, he was, like Karl Marx, a disciple of the philosopher Ludwig Feuerbach. Like Feuerbach, he believed in the possibility of a political revolution that would free mankind from domination and establish an order of freedom. He even took part in the 1849 revolution in Dresden, where he was court Kapellmeister (the name given to the person in charge of music-making), after which he was forced to flee into exile in Switzerland and France. Some traces of Wagner’s early radical political vision remain in the finished work, inspiring Bernard Shaw, in The Perfect Wagnerite (1898), to describe the cycle in Marxist terms, with Siegfried as a revolutionary hero, fighting the monsters of industrial capitalism. Having found himself unable, on this reading, to make sense of Götterdämmerung, Shaw dismissed the last of the four music dramas as mere “grand opera,” arguing that Wagner missed the opportunity, in the character of Siegfried, to deliver the agenda for the new socialist man.

YOU'VE HIT THE LIMIT

You have now reached your limit of 3 free articles in the last 30 days.
But don't worry! You can get another 7 articles absolutely free, simply by entering your email address in the box below.

When you register we'll also send you a free e-book—Writing with punch—which includes some of the finest writing from our archive of 22 years. And we'll also send you a weekly newsletter with the best new ideas in politics and philosophy of culture, which you can of course unsubscribe from at any time

Prospect takes your privacy seriously. We promise never to rent or sell your e-mail address to any third party.
You can unsubscribe from the Prospect e-mail newsletter at any time.

DEBUG messsage: regular

Related articles

Housing for older people: we need a new national strategy to get this right
Clive Betts / February 27, 2018
It’s not just "generation rent" that is struggling; the government must do more to...
Boris Johnson is no Churchill, no matter what he thinks
Sonia Purnell / November 10, 2017
The silly comparisons between these two figures really must stop
Share with friends
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Email

Comments

  1. John R Guyton
    July 3, 2016 at 07:20
    As an American of almost one half Norwegian and German ancestry, I found this piece a wonderful invitation to experience Wagner’s Ring Cycle, whether in person or through DVDs. I’ll keep this article close at hand when I do. The theme line refers to “the eternal conflict between political power and human love.” Political power may be too small a description, however, underestimating Wotan’s role. He keeps order in the universe. Meaning in our lives arises in finite emotive moments as well as in stories that begin and end, whereas sustenance of life runs well beyond our temporospatial horizons. Love belongs to the former, finite category. Followers of monotheistic religions yearn for eternity, as I learned well in the American South, but often struggle to explain what can fill that eternity. Ragnarok of my Viking ancestors – Wagner’s Götterdämmerung – shocked me initially, but it speaks to this fundamental conflict. The only things that can really fill eternity are finite moments and stories of meaning. How that could possibly happen is unclear, as it looks like a cosmic conflict at least from this side of time.
  2. Graham Clark
    July 10, 2016 at 09:53
    Götterdämmerung is grand opera. That's not a "dismiss[al]" by Shaw - the strength of whose critique is probably proven by the resentment it still provokes, but never mind - that's just fact. A plot driven by petty sexual jealousy; a villain who takes advantage of some time alone on stage to tell the audience exactly who he is and what his plans are; a revenge trio; a wedding chorus - the presence of the clichés is undeniable. (And easily explained by the fact, noted by Shaw but not here by Scruton, that most of the text of Götterdämmerung was written before the text of the other operas. Wagner grew into a deeper librettist in the course of writing The Ring, but was, for whatever reason, unwilling to scrap the earlier, lesser parts of the text.) Shaw's reading of The Ring as a communist allegory that goes wrong is an imposition, but at least has something to do with the text and music under discussion, which Scruton's attempt here to beat Wagner's cycle into a conservative morality tale is just unintentionally funny ("Wagner is telling us to hold on to the rule of law as the best kind of government we have. "). If The Ring has any moral at all regarding the rule of law, this is it: once Wotan tries to increase his power by acquiring the titular ring, it's all over. After that, there's no question of holding onto the rule of law. The fall of the gods is certain. The only question is what form that fall will take. Wotan explicitly imagines the conquest of the world by Alberich. Maybe he also hopes that Siegfried might take his place and preside over a benign world order, but that's clearly wishful thinking. In fact, after Wotan takes the ring for himself, there are only two possible outcomes: Either the world continues to exist and is ultimately conquered by evil, or the world escapes from evil by ending altogether. (Granted, the human chorus is technically alive and present at the end, but nobody cares about them. Everything we do care is either already dead before we reach the end of the cycle, or perishes in the fire that consumes Valhalla - except the Rhinemaidens, whom we last see playing in their native water with the ring, finally regained and cleansed of its evil properties. For them, at least, the cycle ends with a return to the state of nature.) What exactly the ring represents is left ambiguous: to the young, Feuerbachian Wagner, presumably money; to the older Wagner, who explicitly associates his ideas with Schopenhauer, presumably desire; maybe most importantly, at all times, Wagner being Wagner, racial contamination. (Wagner's first anti-Semitic pamphlet - "Jewry in Music," 1850 - predates the first draft of "Feuerbach ending" to the Ring by two years - that is, the first ending in which the gods die instead of continuing to rule or being allowed to peacefully retire.)
    1. Alexander Siantonas
      July 18, 2016 at 14:21
      While you are right that Gotterdammerung does does adhere to the conventions of grand opera, I take it that Scruton's point was not to deny this, but to criticise Shaw for failing to take Gotterdammerung seriously as contributing to the overall meaning of the cycle. As to your account of the Ring and the rule of law, I think matters are a little more complicated than you suggest. The issue is not so much Wotan's seizure of the ring itself (recall that Erda's warning was initially supposed to be conditional on possession of the ring, but became unconditional). Wotan's position depends upon Valhalla, and Wotan only gets Valhalla one of three ways: refusing to honour his contract (and so destroying the rule of law), handing over Freia herself (and so love and beauty personified, a worse crime than Alberich's forging the ring), or handing over the ring. Thus, as is clear from Erda's unconditional warning, all is already over, whether or not Wotan takes and keeps the ring. The moral Scruton draws, conservative as it might be, is not much of an imposition. We have the the rule of law, compromised and fragile, in Wotan; love without law in the Siegfried and Brunnhilde of Gotterdammerung, just as destructive as Scruton says; hate without law in Alberich and company; and the state of nature in the Rhinemaidens. It's pretty plausible that the rule of law is the least bad of the options we are offered.
  3. Tom Goff
    July 13, 2016 at 17:17
    Eloquent defense of Wagner's ideas, which retain some value despite their disturbing subtext.
  4. BMerker
    July 13, 2016 at 18:53
    "Their one thought, on encountering others, is to make use of them. [...] Everything in the world of Nibelheim is a means, and nothing is an end in itself." Apparently an echo of Kantian ethics
  5. Malcolm Craig
    July 24, 2016 at 19:16
    An interesting interpretation, but - as one of the commenters above has already noted - a little unconvincing. Wagner is plainly *not* on the side of law: Scruton has glossed over the point that Wotan's spear, the concrete embodiment of law, was torn from a branch of the world-ash, and that this action (which parallels the theft of the Rheingold) has led to the tree withering away. For Wagner, the contractual or 'consensual' authority of Licht-Alberich is little better than the 'coercive' authority of Schwarz-Alberich, as it is Wotan's law-upholding power that condemns Sieglinde to forced marriage and which demands Siegmund's death. This is a long way from the conservative parable that Scruton imagines the Ring to be.

Prospect's free newsletter

The big ideas that are shaping our world—straight to your inbox. PLUS a free e-book and 7 articles of your choosing on the Prospect website.

Prospect takes your privacy seriously. We promise never to rent or sell your e-mail address to any third party.

This Month's Magazine

Perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus.

Time to rip up the economics textbook and start again? Howard Reed says the discipline needs rebuilding from first principles. Also: Sonia Purnell on Jacob Rees-Mogg's chance of cracking No 10; Will Self on his first acid trip

Subscribe

Most Popular

  • Read
  • Commented

Leonard Bernstein invented how we do modern classical music

Rules of origin: the biggest Brexit problem you didn’t know about



Can Jacob Rees-Mogg become Britain’s 55th prime minister—and Eton’s 20th?

“All the justifications for Brexit are being dismantled”—The MEPs fighting to stop British departure

In defence of the economists

6 Comments

Why I won’t be leaving Labour over anti-semitism

3 Comments

Rip it up and start again: the case for a new economics

3 Comments

Can Jacob Rees-Mogg become Britain’s 55th prime minister—and Eton’s 20th?

3 Comments

Brexit will no longer be a significant event

3 Comments

About this author

Roger Scruton
Roger Scruton is a philosopher. His latest book is "Our Church: A Personal History of the Church of England" (Atlantic)
More by this author

More by Roger Scruton

Who are we?
July 14, 2016
Book review: The True Cost of Economics by Philip Roscoe
January 23, 2014
Poverty, the market and the state
November 26, 2013

Next Prospect events

  • Details

    Prospect Book Club—Jesse Norman

    London, 2018-07-16

  • Details

    Prospect Book Club—Henry Marsh

    London, 2018-06-18

  • Details

    HowTheLightGetsIn 2018

    Hay-on-Wye, 2018-05-25

See more events

Sponsored features

  • Supporting UK businesses trading overseas

  • The Commonwealth has put vision for everyone on the world’s agenda— now we must act

  • Brexit and the future of industry

  • Seeing Clearly

  • Meet the brains behind Exo

PrimeTime

Prospect was originally founded by Editor David Goodhart and Publisher Derek Coombs, as a home for intelligent debate. The magazine is owned and supported by the Resolution Group, as part of its not-for-profit, public interest activities. The aim is to tackle the big challenges confronting society, through rigorous thinking and fine writing.

Follow us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • RSS

Editorial

Editor: Tom Clark
Deputy Editor: Steve Bloomfield
Executive Editor: Jay Elwes
Managing Editor (Arts & Books): Sameer Rahim
Head of Digital: Stephanie Boland
Deputy Digital Editor (Political Correspondent): Alex Dean
Design: Mike Turner
Production Editor: Chris Tilbury
US Writer-at-Large: Sam Tanenhaus

Commercial

Commercial Director: Alex Stevenson
Finance Manager: Pauline Joy
Head of Marketing: Paul Mortimer
Marketing and Circulations Executive: James Hawkins
Head of Research and Engagement: Saskia Perriard-Abdoh
Events Coordinator: Oliver Ward
Head of Advertising Sales: Adam Kinlan 020 3372 2934
Senior Account Manager: Sophie Ryan 020 3372 2927
Senior Account Manager: Dominic Slonecki 0203 372 2972
Account Manager: Scott Smith 020 3372 2931

  • Home
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Acceptable Use Policy
© Prospect Publishing Limited
×
Login
Login with your subscriber account:
You need a valid subscription to login.
I am
Remember Me


Forgotten password?

Or enter with social networking:
Login to post comments using social media accounts.
  • With Twitter
  • Connect
  • With Google +
×
Register Now

Register today and access any 7 articles on the Prospect’s website for FREE in the next 30 days..
PLUS find out about the big ideas that will shape our world—with Prospect’s FREE newsletter sent to your inbox. We'll even send you our e-book—Writing with punch—with some of the finest writing from the Prospect archive, at no extra cost!

Not Now, Thanks

Prospect takes your privacy seriously. We promise never to rent or sell your e-mail address to any third party.
You can unsubscribe from the Prospect e-mail newsletter at any time.

×
You’ve got full access!

It looks like you are a Prospect subscriber.

Prospect subscribers have full access to all the great content on our website, including our entire archive.

If you do not know your login details, simply close this pop-up and click 'Login' on the black bar at the top of the screen, then click 'Forgotten password?', enter your email address and press 'Submit'. Your password will then be emailed to you.

Thank you for your support of Prospect and we hope that you enjoy everything the site has to offer.

This site uses cookies to improve the user experience. By using this site, you agree that we can set and use these cookies. For more details on the cookies we use and how to manage them, see our Privacy and Cookie Policy.