Boston reinvented itself when its manufacturing industries declined. Should cities that don’t manage this be abandoned?by James Crabtree / February 23, 2011 / Leave a comment
Published in March 2011 issue of Prospect Magazine
Boston rising: the city reinvented itself when its manufacturing industries declined. Should cities that don’t manage this be abandoned?
Few recent proposals to boost growth have gone down as badly as shutting Sunderland. Yet in 2008, the centre-right think tank Policy Exchange was condemned for a publication that appeared to say just that. The idea of encouraging struggling towns to decline further might seem crazy. But behind it lies the work of the American economist Edward Glaeser, whose controversial thinking holds important clues about how to restart Britain’s faltering economy.
Those trying to cobble together a growth plan for the coalition are unlikely to have Policy Exchange’s report high on their reading list, but its argument is more reasonable than it at first appears. Much public money is spent propping up fading towns and cities, like Sunderland or Liverpool. Much better, the report argued, to push development in places where people and businesses actually want to move to or set up shop, like Cambridge or Leeds.