Yesterday’s launch of Labour’s justice strategy under Sadiq Khan extends the new leadership’s challenge of new Labour orthodoxies. “Tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime” will no longer be the mantra now that Ed Miliband’s ‘new generation’ have taken power.
Instead, Khan suggests, the party must acknowledge that its “scorecard in office would have said: ‘could have done better’” over re-offending rates and the size of the prison population. He speaks convincingly about the need to “draw upon facts, rather than emotional rhetoric, to steer the debate”, because “it’s easy to slip into polarised… positions when discussing our justice system.”
He continues: “The work that we did to prevent youth offending, and to tackle the roots of criminality and combat social deprivation, was drowned out by debates on prisons and being tough on criminals.”
But while Khan is right to ask questions about how the coalition has managed to successfully position itself as more progressive than the Blair and Brown administrations, he fails to acknowledge the role that new Labour’s tough rhetoric helped in the fight against crime. With Liberal Democrats in government, and the famously liberal Ken Clarke at the head of coalition justice policy, there is the problem that fear of a lurch to the left on justice policy will leave the door wide open for a resurgent right-wing.