Why do we teach children two different systems of handwriting? © Cybrarian77
There’s something deeply peculiar about the way we teach children to play the violin. It’s a very difficult skill for them to master—getting their fingers under control, holding the bow properly, learning how to move it over the strings without scratching and slipping. But just as they are finally getting there, are beginning to feel confident, to hit the right notes, to sound a bit like the musicians they hear, we break the news to them: we’ve taught them to play left-handed, but now it’s time to do it like grown-ups do, the other way around.
Alright, I’m fibbing. Of course we don’t teach violin that way. We wouldn’t do anything so absurd for something as important as learning an instrument, would we? No—but that’s how we teach children to write.
It’s best not to examine the analogy too deeply, but you see the point. The odd thing is that, when most parents watch their child’s hard-earned gains in forming letters like those printed in their storybooks crumble under the demand that they now relearn the art of writing “joined up” (“and don’t forget the joining tail!”), leaving their calligraphy a confused scrawl of extraneous cusps and wiggles desperately seeking a home, they don’t ask what on earth the school thinks it is doing. They smile, comforted that their child is starting to write like them.
As he or she probably will. The child may develop the same abominable scribble that gets letters misdirected and medical prescriptions perilously misread. In his impassioned plea for the art of good handwriting, Philip Hensher puts his finger on the issue (while apparently oblivious to it):
“You longed to do ‘joined-up writing,’ as we used to call the cursive hand when we were young… I looked forward to the ability to join one letter to another as a mark of huge sophistication. Adult handwriting was unreadable, true, but perhaps that was its point.”
The real point is, of course, that “sophistication.” When I questioned my friend, a primary school teacher, about the value of teaching cursive, she was horrified. “But otherwise they’d have baby writing!” she exclaimed. I pointed out that my handwriting is printed (the so-called “manuscript” form). “Oh no, yours is fine,” she—not the placatory sort—allowed. I didn’t ask whether…
tyronen
rationalbloke
Philip Ball
Carlos Gershenson
Geraldine Carter
Philip Ball
Jimhaz
Andrew Levin
Jim Johnston
Aksel J.
Louis Candell
Sophie Aimer
Andrew
Marlon
Besitz Belastet
Elle Martini
;lj;lkj
Chris
Len
Besitz Belastet
Jim
Muggins
Philip Ball
Stephanie
Bob Bell
Tom
Neko
Neko
Kitty Florey
HDoug
Alan
Joe Orbachov
charlotte
Nan Jay Barchowsky
luke
Barb
Ford
Thomas Root
Don Phillipson
Suzanne
Bob
Leigh
Janet
modalursine
Gail
Sam
Dave Pickett
Philip Ball
nietky
Catherine
Alberto
Ophelia Stimpson
Philip Ball
Catherine
Gene Manfra
John
susan
susan
Philip Ball
Mateusz
susan
susan
Philip Ball
susan
susan
susan
chris
LeoL
david woodward
HDoug
Deborah Hemstreet
Angus Armour
Gene Manfra
Nan Jay Barchowsky
Muggins
John
Peter Piper
Olivia
Heidi Cole
Bob Jones
Tony Knox
Poorvaj
Paul
Max
Camille
Adriane Baldwin
Natalie
JuuRokuChan
Al_de_Baran
Kate Gladstone
Carlos
Carlos
Dimitry V.
Kate Gladstone
Kate Gladstone
w tym
Daniel Stern
Bob
loren
Kate Gladstone