One of the distinctive features of French intellectual life in the post-war period has been the influence of the German philosopher Martin Heidegger (1889-1976). Heidegger’s standing among French philosophers, especially those working in the phenomenological tradition (who are more numerous in France than anywhere else in Europe, let alone the Anglophone world), contrasts dramatically with his reputation in the country of his birth, where his legacy is tainted irredeemably by his political compromises with National Socialism in the 1930s.
The precise nature and extent of those compromises remain a matter of controversy—not least in France, where the murky subject of Heidegger’s political affiliations convulses the intellectual class roughly once a decade. Last week, Nicolas Weill, a journalist at Le Monde, wrote on his blog that the latest volume of Heidegger’s complete works (the Gesamtausgabe), which will be published in Germany in March next year, promises a definitive answer to the question whether “Heidegger was an intellectual led astray by a temporary will to power or whether his political itinerary reflects a more profound tendency”.
Eric Aeschimann, writing in Le Nouvel Observateur, reports that Heidegger’s Schwarzen Hefte (“Black Notebooks”) will trouble even the most faithful of his acolytes in France. It appears that the German editor of the notebooks, Peter Trawny, has written an essay entitled “Heidegger: ‘The Black Notebooks’ and Historial Antisemitism” (“historial” being one of those neologisms of which Heidegger, and Heideggerians, were and are fond) in which he argues that these manuscripts, written between 1931 and 1946, contain ideas that are “clearly antisemitic, even if it is not a question of antisemitism of the kind promoted by Nazi ideology.” One of Heidegger’s French translators, Hadrien France-Lanord, has read Trawny’s essay and has pronounced himself dismayed by many of the extracts from the notebooks that it contains. We are, Aeschimann writes, on the verge of another “Heidegger affair”.
Trent
ortega
Gene Schulman
g. hayes
Lucien Aychenwald
Vance McLaughlin
Lucien Aychenwald
Santiago
Kyle
Tom Blancato
Andrew
Sean Matthews
Gregory Peterson
Mark Titus
Crispin Sartwell
Greg Desilet
Al_de_Baran
Mike Cope
Greg Desilet
B. Switzer
Gene Schulman
Theryn Lyes
Greg Desilet
John Primitivo Orosco
John Primitivo Orosco
Cedric
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Martin
DSteiner
DSteiner
Mark Titus
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
DSteiner
Terrence O'Keeffe
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Greg Desilet
Quixote
Quixote
Sue
StephenKMackSD
DSteiner
foolswritingonphilosophy
Samuel Ogbonna
Greg Desilet
Gene Schulman
Gene Schulman
Sam Ogbonna
Gene Schulman
Dr. Margit Appleton
Jacob Arnon
Jackson Davis
Sergiu
Sam Ogbonna